Are You Normal?

Ask your question today!

Assuming God exists, (S)He is essentially only human. Yay or nay?
Favorited (undo) 18 Comments

I've noticed how believers worship God as being this awesome, all-powerful, all-loving being... but prayers go unanswered all the time, blatant injustices are ignored for long periods, and we all behave screwed-up.
Re: punishment - I don't believe there is such a thing as an unfair one.

The reason for all this: If there really is only ONE God who made humankind, then surely He must have some human essence. Being human, He is more than likely not as wonderful as we would like to think.

Please back up with Scripture/personal experience, if at all possible.
9
5
3
3
25
0
2
2
9
0
9
Skip & see results
Next >>
Does this post fit one of these flags? If so, click it! [Off Topic] [Inappropriate] [Best Of] [Vulgar] [Funny] [Fake] [Weird] [Interesting] [Stupid] [Lame] [Messed Up]
Comments (18)
God made man in his own image. In regards to your second answer jesus, god and the holy spirit are one in the same. In regards to the entire post humans are the result of over 3 billion years of evolution, please nobody reply to this as I'm not getting into a debate about evolution again with a bunch of fucking idiots.
Comment Hidden (show)
-
@: Darkoil
If we're the "fucking idiots", then can you tell me what created God?

-Can God create a weight so heavy that not even he could lift?
-Can God put a limit to his own power?
-If God is willing to stop evil, but not able, then he is not omnipotent.
If God is able, but not willing, then he is malevolent.
If he is both able, and willing, then whence cometh evil?
If God is not willing nor able, then why call him God?
-What is the point of life? If you say that it's a test, then (if God is truly omnipotent) God should be able to tell immediatly if we're evil or not. No test would be necessary.
-If God is omnipotent, then he can see the future. If he is omnipotent, then he can also change that future. If he can change it, then the previous prediction was wrong, meaning he's not all-knowing. If he can't change it, then he isn't all-knowing.

Listen to logic, it can help.
(Sorry if some of the spelling is bad, I'm on a Nook)
Comment Hidden (show)
-
That, and if God created people in his own image, then why are there lame (crippled) people? Why are there people born with no brains, only brainstems? Why are there mentally retarted people? Do you mean to tell me that God is mentally retarted, crippled, and brainless? Sure sounds like something I'd put my faith in.
Comment Hidden (show)
-
I don't believe in God you complete and utter moron.
Comment Hidden (show)
-
@: Darkoil
Well you clearly believe in creationism... how can ayone believe in creationism but not call themselves religious?
Comment Hidden (show)
-
Again you are wrong. My original post was a simple jest at what was originally written in the question but I do believe it has been changed since. If you must know I am a scientist and I think the very idea of religion existing in this age is pathetic.
Comment Hidden (show)
@: Darkoil
Someone only wants opinions if they're the same as theirs.

ROFFLEPLEBROFFLE
Comment Hidden (show)
-
Evolution isn't an opinion.
Comment Hidden (show)
This poll is a massive facepalm. Can't believe people are giving serious answers.
Comment Hidden (show)
Here is one way you can view prayers...
If you pray for patience, God will not just give it to you, He will give you the opportunity to express or find patience.
Comment Hidden (show)
-
@: lulz
And sometimes he does so by enabling genocide and war crimes, with the occasional massive earthquake or flood.

God works in mysterious (atrocious) ways!

Sorry, I couldn't resist.
Comment Hidden (show)
-
I like you...
Comment Hidden (show)
As for injustices going on today, I think it's pointless when people say "why does God let bad shit happen?" because we really DON'T know what a hypothetical god does and does not let happen. For all we know, the world could be this bad even with His damage control, and the world would be 10x worse if He weren't intervening. Horrible things could be happening to prevent even worse things from happening. You could say, if He was all-powerful He could stop both from happening. Sure, that's true, but maybe He created His own guidelines to work within; His own rules in some cosmic game where He's the only player, if that makes sense. He chooses put the limitations on Himself, for one reason or another, but there is still nothing external that can limit Him.

This is not an argument for the existence of a god, just an alternate view I feel the need to point out.

All of that could apply to any hypothetical god, but the rest of what I'm about to say refers to the Christian God.

"Re: punishment - I don't believe there is such a thing as an unfair one."

I get the sense that you're mainly referencing Christianity (sorry if that's not the case), and I think you have a fundamental misunderstanding (or disagreement?) with this Biblical principle: God is not a fair God. If He were fair, we'd ALL be in Hell because according to the Bible that's what we all deserve. He is not obligated to save any of us, but because He is merciful He will save those who seek Him. (I'm not necessarily stating my beliefs here, just stating what the Bible says).

"If there really is only ONE God who made humankind, then surely He must have some human essence."

I don't see why that has to be true, but maybe I'm just missing something.

"He is more than likely not as wonderful as we would like to think."

I ponder on this a lot, actually. It goes back to the old Greek question, are the gods holy or did they create holiness? If holiness exists independently of God, does that mean He's not all-powerful? If God created holiness, does that mean He's an arbitrary God, and He simply gets to decide what is good/bad based on His own whims or agenda, therefore nothing is essentially holy? It's a paradox.

The Bible is clear about one thing, though, even if modern Christians choose to ignore doctrine in favor a fluffy, feel-good Christianity. "Evil" is simply anything that is not what God wants. People almost never set out to do evil things. Someone could have the best intentions and look like saints to other people, and still be considered evil by God. Sinning is simply missing the mark. Your average person would probably be considered "evil," right along with your Hitlers and serial killers. It's a lot harsher than most Christians are willing to admit.

Sorry for the rambling, I just ponder this stuff a lot and like to hear what other people think. I'm also always interested to hear if I've overlooked something or if there's a counter argument to what I say, so feel free to reply.
Comment Hidden (show)
-
@: EllaG
You know how in the bible they say that God made humans in his image and yet there are slight differences in every person? What it suggests is that God has many forms and I feel that is hinting to us God exists only in the people who believe him.

Also assuming that God does exist, shouldn't we then bow down to the creator of God instead? Which will be followed by an infinite continuim of worshipping the creator of the person who created god and so on and so forth.
Comment Hidden (show)
@: EllaG
Your first paragraph would be relevant if that was in line with any scripture in contemporary mainstream religion. Atrocities occur - this implies that god is either not perfectly powerful or not perfectly moral, and while these hypothetical imperfect gods sound more probable to me, but I don't think that's what most people believe. The unfair God you refer to in your punishment paragraph is the lawful God of the Old Testament, as opposed to the indiscriminately gracious God of the New Testament. I get the feeling that most people have disavowed most of "old" God's hazy morality. You imply this in your second to last paragraph, but I feel like this renders some of your earlier logic kind of invalid.
Comment Hidden (show)
I personally prefer the vengeful, hair-trigger tempered God of the Old Testament by far. The New Testament suffers from typical sequel problems and limitations imo.
Comment Hidden (show)
hes an na'vi
Comment Hidden (show)
i think god is manic depressive and that we're his favorites. i have a lot of thoughts on what god might be but i don't think i can explain them all here...
Comment Hidden (show)

Sorry, you need to be signed in to comment.

Click here to sign in or register.