The two girls are both healthy.
The first girl is thick. Shes got big boobs and a big ass. She's got a bigger frame than most girls and according to some guys, "has meat on her bones". I won't say she's curvy although she is, she's heavier than a classic hourglass shape.So I think she's more thick than curvy.
The second girl is slim, average sized boobs and an average sized ass, but she does have boobs and ass. Slim, lean and athletic overall.
Please be honest here. Guys claim they like "thick" girls, maybe a little bit overweight. But in fact at the end of the day slim chicks or chicks of average weight get all the attention.
The first girl is thick. Shes got big boobs and a big ass. She's got a bigger frame than most girls and according to some guys, "has meat on her bones". I won't say she's curvy although she is, she's heavier than a classic hourglass shape.So I think she's more thick than curvy.
The second girl is slim, average sized boobs and an average sized ass, but she does have boobs and ass. Slim, lean and athletic overall.
Please be honest here. Guys claim they like "thick" girls, maybe a little bit overweight. But in fact at the end of the day slim chicks or chicks of average weight get all the attention.

You obviously have missed the point of why men say they like women with meat on their bones, most of the time they mean that when compared to an anorexic female, not a healthy, athletic female.
I don't want a girl that's heavier than me.
(even if the BOOBS and ass were smaller than average, it's still the better option.)
To answer your question, I couldn't make a decision based on the information given. It could be either girl; whichever I clicked with, I guess. It it was the bigger girl, I'd go for her. If it was the slim girl, then it'd be her.
lol im a "birdie" too ! a parakeet to be specific
ohh i hate politically right normal answers. you are not odd at all.
I'll go with the slim one.
If there's ever a situation where i have to support her(e.g. walking home and she's dead-drunk), rescue her(pull her out of a crashed car and to safety) or situations in which we have to share a crowded space(sleeping in a small guest bed together, taking a bath together), etc....
it will simply be more "practical" to have another slim girl with me.
And yes, i admit i probably also like the way she looks better. I'm self-conscious about my body, and i'd prefer a partner that kind of confirms me in the ideal i see for myself.