I dont think there can be a god because a majority of the worlds population is in a famine, diseased and dying. If there is a god why does he allow this? and why should we worship him for doing this? Theres millions of diseases and people getting murdered and only a complete douchebag would allow this to happen. So this is what I narrowed it down too.
1) there is no god
2) god is a complete asshole and should not be worshiped by anyone but the murderers.
The meaning of life is to reproduce, we live, eat, drink, fuck, sleep then die. Thats the whole meaning of existence
People like all the prophets were great people they preached peace and all that stuff and I agree with that, but I do not believe in god.
If there is then the first thing I'm going to say to him when he's judging me is why the fuck does he tortures billions of people.
There are also flaws in religions which people from that religion tend to overlook. heres an example
"God controls everything we do, and what we think" Then why do we torture and kill?
I believe that there is a higher consciousness than us. but i don't believe it's holy. Its just a being, or beings, living in a different dimension of space and time. Kind of like the way you kill thousands of bacterium when you wipe your kitchen counter clean. You are god in that situation, but you dont think of it that way. you just do what you do. Thats how god is.
God is wiping the counter top we live on. and some other god is wiping the counter top he/she/it lives on. etc etc.
that's my view. what do you think?
but while i thinks it's pretty obvious that it would kind of stupid to do that everybody else keeps doing it
the only thing i can figure is that my brain level is like over 9,000!!! and everybody elses is like at 17.
GET A BRAIN MORANS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Religion is all just superstition, An irrational belief that an object, action, or circumstance not logically related to a course of events influences its outcome, and I am not superstitious and it seems some people I know make fun of superstitious people and then go to church and praise god.....
OH well I only believe in logical shit and I like some books about that stuff too, like Bill Bryson's book on a short hghistory of nearly everything, I find them interesting.
the sad part is that these "fairytales" were made up by cavemen who thought that the sun was pulled by a chariot
and now we are in 2008 and we have science to explain things we don't understand, yet people are still TOO STUPID TO GET IT!
How do you not understand something when everything is already explained but people still make things up and really believe it!
But I stopped caring about trying to prove religious people wrong at about the age of 9 years old.
I was born and raised as a mormon and they do some serious brainwashing in that church. Well at about the age of 7 years old I started questioning it and i would get into like hour long debates with people. Now i just don't give a shit, but it still amazed me how dumb people are.
If I were to try to debate with somebody that, it would have be under the pretenses of "are we really doing this" "are like 5 years old and have the brain capacity of a caveman?"
fascinating. :D.
I was born and raised a catholic, till I got out of my catholic school at least, I started questioning god straight after my first holy communion, ironic huh?, in the second grade. I don't know when my mum stopped believing in god but my granddad is a very big catholic and I have like 20 bibles all givin to me by him. I put them up in the attic so they would be closer to god :)He's making a book about how to be a better catholic, and I'm going to put it up there and never read the first page.
Most the people I know believe in god because they were raised as whatever religion they are and don't question it. I have no respect for anyone that doesn't question their religion and just blindly follows it, I have respect for those who question it and still completely believe it's the correct answer though. Unfortunately there are a lot of people that refuse to listen to the facts of evolution and only try to find the flaws and never look for flaws in their religion.
My friend believes god created the earth, put the first living organisms here, then let evolution run its course and let us live free without any more interference, she thought about it and thinks that is the best answer, though I think she might change her mind when she studies evolution in school, that turned my other friend, who couldn't understand why I don't believe in creationism, too he can't understand why other people believe in creationism.
I don't really like organized religions anyway, they tell you a load of shit that is based off of nothing and expect the entire world too believe that one religion is true.
When I see the sun coming across the sky, I know it would not possibly happen if someone were not pulling it across the heavens in a chariot. That "someone", my friend, is the God Apollo. Kneel, heathen.
You see, I don't care what "science" has to say. I know that today's "science" is all lies to weaken your mind.
Praise Zeus.
Whats not to believe about all the mythology, Kronos fucked his sister then ate all his children then his son, Zeus, killed his father then married and fucked his sister who then became jealous of anyone his brother, husband, and who know what else, started to have non incest sex with. I'm sure Zeus is from the south.
Completely believable right there :)
SO science is all lies to weaken your mind and religion isnt???
So god sent us in this world to test our deeds , If we worship god and obey his commandments given in His Holy Books according to one's Religion
For christians = Bible
For Muslims = Holy Quran
For Hindus = Vedas
ect
.
.
.
we will receive the reward in the next life which is eternal & starts after this life ends (after death) !
We will go to heaven if our deeds are good and we will go to HELL if our deeds are bad !
All major Religions have many common things for example
1- There is only ONE TRUE GOD [Not Jesus(May God Be Pleased With Him) Jesus(May God Be Pleased With Him) was one of the messengers of GOD but he was not GOD]
2- We should not lie, drink alcohol,and lots of other bad things are prohibited in Christianity , Islam ,Hinduism & other major religions
there are so many more things i can describe with detail and context !
So god sent us in this world to test our deeds , If we worship god and obey his commandments given in His Holy Books according to one's Religion
For christians = Bible
For Muslims = Holy Quran
For Hindus = Vedas
ect
.
.
.
we will receive the reward in the next life which is eternal & starts after this life ends (after death) !
We will go to heaven if our deeds are good and we will go to HELL if our deeds are bad !
All major Religions have many common things for example
1- There is only ONE TRUE GOD [Not Jesus(May God Be Pleased With Him) Jesus(May God Be Pleased With Him) was one of the messengers of GOD but he was not GOD]
2- We should not lie, drink alcohol,and lots of other bad things are prohibited in Christianity , Islam ,Hinduism & other major religions
there are so many more things i can describe with detail and context !
The World , materials , atmosphere , stars , SUN, solar system etc dosnt came into to existence on there own some one created all that so perfectly that know one can even imagine of creating .000001% of that & that some one is GOD !
GOD is not comparable to anything in this universe !
The moment you compare GOD to anything it is not GOD!
For example you say My GOD is 1 million times stronger than the Strongest man on the earth then it is not god
GOD is uncreated and have no gender or image what so ever !
The Question Who Created GOD is illogical
its like asking a that does you friend John (male) gave birth to a boy or girl ?
That may be the way for you, but not everyone. I'm not going to be the crazy Jesus freak or anything, but I do believe there is a God and that one can have a personal relationship with him.
I have tried to explain this to people who consider themselves atheist about all that goes wrong in the world. The reason why it does is because man has a free will, and he can choose to do whatever he wants with it.
There is a song out now called "no handlebars" by the Flobots and if you read the lyrics it will help you better understand how much power man really has. It is a choice and some people do not care about how their choices effect the lives of others, unfortunately.
Just be thankful you are not any of those people, and try to help them in anyway you can.
And anyway it doesnt matter if it's depressing or not, it's (possibly) the truth, the truth isn't meant to be some romantic ass shit the chances are it is a depressing thing.
BTW this is the guythatposted
And I would rather believe iin him he not be there than to not believe and find out he is there
You will burn in hell then!!!!
If god wants people to believe that he exists then he should make evidence, like himself come down to earth or something, because all we have to say he exists are people telling you he does and people writing shit.
I personally understand what you went through I had to go to church and had to go to christian school. Once I turned 18 I bolted and haven't looked back since.
Honestly, I know this is going to sound crazy, but I think the reason why there is so much pain and suffering along with all the crazies who cause it is because we are overly populated!!!
science? lies? FUCK YOU. science is backed up by FACTS. if you deny FACTS, then deny gravity, deny life, deny everything you know. deny that your mother is really your mother. WHAT. WHAT NOW. GOT ANYTHING ELSE TO SAY, BITCH?
I think science is true and that there is no god but not everyone does, and you should respect that.
Maybe you are right. Or maybe it's random. if you typed in random letters from a typewriter for 1 million years, for example, you'd probably come up with at least a few pages from Shakespeare or Doskiofsky or at least Steven King. so maybe in an infinite universe with infinite time, things fall into place once in a while. maybe we will find out that it has fallen into place in many other parts of the universe as well.
God created Eve from Adam's rib. Now, all the cells in Adam's rib would have an X and a Y chromosome in the 23rd pair. Having been created out of Adam's rib, Eve would also have the same chromosomes as Adam, which makes Eve (Steve?) male and both of them homosexual. So the first "book" of the Bible proves that it is self-inconsistent because supposedly Adam and Eve had three children - which couldn't happen. Of course, we can avoid this problem if we assume that god performed a miracle about which we've not been told. This is generally the answer given when believers don't have an answer.
For god's sake, let's assume that said miracle was performed and all the Y chromosomes were replaced by X chromosomes before Adam and Eve (Steve?) did the "giggity giggity" and created three boys.
Finally the boys grew up, and since they were forbidden to pork their mother, they went out and found some new hoes that hopefully hadn't been tapped yet...wait...the only other people on the planet were their parents!
Unless...unless...either they f*cked their sisters - or another miracle occurred about which we've also not been told and god created some b1tches for them to...well, you know.
If they hooked up with their sisters (who would have to be geneticaly identical to them and their parents, by the way), we have our very first incestuous relationships and we've barely gotten started!
Since everyone is genetically identical, this would explain why there are so many idiots on the planet today.
Another annoying problem that won't go away is the whole Noah's flood thing.
Supposedly, it rained alot and there was a flood that covered the earth to the tops of the highest mountains. Because Noah was tight with god (or The Weather Channel), he had advanced warning about this and built a big, shiny boat so he and his family and all the other animals (besides humans) would survive. (No mention is made of all the plant species that would die from the flood, so we have to assume he brought samples of them, too.)
Noah Question 1: Where did all the water come from? If you (that is, god) were to melt all the ice on Earth *and* gather all the water vapor from the atmosphere, you (she) wouldn't even come close to drowning the planet. The oceans would have to be almost 7 miles deeper than they are today and there's not near enough water on the planet to do that.
What? Another miracle?
Noah Question 2: Why is there a Texas Blind Salamander? Supposedly, Noah gathered pairs of all the animals (and, presumably plants) and put them on his big, shiny boat so they wouldn't be swept away by the mean and nasty flood. However, I think we can safely assume that Noah never visited San Marcos, Texas, which was the only location on the planet where he could have collected the Texas Blind Salamander. This salamander is not adapted to salt water and would have been extincted by the flood of seawater. The same argument applies to innumerable other species about which Noah could not have known, but still exist today.
Let me guess - a miracle?
Noah Question 3: Where did all the water go after the flood was over?
I know, I know. Yet another miracle, right?
By the way, a Christian friend of mine told me that after Noah's canoe trip with his family, Noah accidentally drank some fermented grape juice and got so drunk that he took his clothes off. Can you imagine the horror?
When his sons discovered this, they walked backwards into his tent with a blanket to cover his nakedness. They walked backwards because apparently it's a sin for a child to see his parent naked. (My son and daughter are going to hell since I almost never wear clothes!)
Anyway, one of Noah's pervert boys "accidentally" saw his father's d1ck and, according to my friend, was turned into a black man. So, this is where black people came from! And all this time I thought dark skin was an evolutionary response to abundant UV light. Silly me!
Your argument for life on other planets(which I agree with, btw) is the same argument for the existence of other dimensions which we are not able to perceive and which contain life forms we are not aware of (although they may or may not be aware of us).
I believe there are much quicker ways to get to places that are billions of years away. I believe that our sense of space is largely an illusion, and that it is possible to be instantly in another place we currently think of as being "far away".
Well when I said billions of years I meant billions of LIGHT years, a shit load faster than just us in a rocket. We haven't been able to get anything to the speed of light yet, let alone even faster. A teleporter will only really work if one of 2 things happen, one it makes a clone of you, in every possible way, memories, way you think, all that shit, I mean the whole you walk into a machine then you walk out somewhere else clone not the kind that we can do today. Or 2) it takes us apart an atom at a time and sends us there, though even if we culd do that and not lose many atoms in the process the whole speed thing is still a problem seeing as those atoms will need to travel billions times faster than the speed of light to reach some planets that may, or may not, have life on it.
If you take every atom on this planet and randomly tossed them onto other planets, theres a high chance that none of them are close than hundreds of light years apart.
when we get over this limitation, we will be able to travel to "far off" places, billions of light years away because the nature of the 3 spacial dimensions we exist in is not what it seems.
i believe that what we THINK to be linear distance is actually a folded curvy expanse wrapped around other dimensions. by accessing the other dimensions, we should be able to traverse our "huge distances" instantly, or in significantly less "time".
the concept of "wormholes" existing in our universe is part of this idea. the theory behind this is too expansive to put in this type of forum.
See what I'm saying though?
Also the universe also bends everything in it bends it, the planets, the stars, the black holes everything. If you bend it enough you can instantly go from one place to another, I can't remember if this is a worm hole or something different entirely, what I do know is that this creates a shit load of gravity and it would take longer fighting all of that gravity than it would making something do this, also if you leave the universe bent with all of that gravity pushing on it it then causes a black hole.
like if you were a being who only understood length and width, but not height, and I folded your space so that one flap of the plane you existed within was ON TOP of another part of that plane(ON TOP being something you have no perception of)you would have no way of knowing that a "far away" point was actually right next to you. You would perceive the distance to that far away point as being at a linear distance.
That's the illusion we live under now.
about time this debate got more interesting. go see the other debates, like the one named "i hate christians". i looked at this for half a second and decided it was ullshit, so i fucked off a bit and went to another. its a bit late today and i got a whole lot to say. hf, ill be back tomorrow ^^
religion, especially christianity, limits our very RIGHT as atheists. it was not recorded, however, in an interview, george bush stated himself that he did not consider atheists to be patriotic or citizens of america. while over 95 percent of the population would vote for homosexuals or blacks, only 49% would vote for atheists as president.
in this world, especially in america, atheists are muchly hated, and are treated as badly as blacks 50 years ago. Many educated personnel on the american counsil had to fake their beliefs in order to be elected. Considering america was founded by men stating that religion should never mix with politics, this country has become a disgrace to it's founders.
from the crusades to modern day racism against atheism, i can honestly say, religion has always been, and always will be, for as long as it exists, an interferance to the proper education of science, and according to your statement, your life. you may not notice it, but the older you get, the more you realise, how much religion has taken away from you. even though religion was taken out of the school education system, there are always presentations on the subject from many churches, and the kids ranging from kindergarden to high school are forced to listen. those kids know only to obey the teacher. they don't even know about religious freedom. to them, they have no choice. it is the same as forcing a child to become christian/morman/whatever religion.
i have experienced this myself when i was 8. i did not know i could leave at any time. and at the time, if a student tried to leave, the teacher would not allow it. i remember the great impact the bible they gave us and the words they gave us had on us. children that young, who does not even have the generally accepted, by science, and by the education system, the big bang theory, already being fed religion. why are children learning a hypothesis, or even a lie, before learning what is accepted by the scientific and educational community as a fact and truth?
those children are easily convinced and manipulated through complicated and hard-to-comprehend words of religion, and, due to human curiosity, every child is bound to have thought of the question, "how did we exist."
most parents would simply say, "you are too young", and leave the kids wondering. how grateful would the kids be, after all that time, to learn what they thought was "the truth"? they wouldn't even understand what a religion was. they'd think that it is the truth. once a child learns something, it is very difficult to change their minds. this is how religion is spread. once you tell a child, who wants nothing more than happiness, and to have fun, that by believing in god they will be forevermore happy, how will you ever convince them otherwise?
how is it that religion has ever been removed from schools? all of what i have written clearly shows, even though it is out of the official system, it is still part of the unofficial one, as a "school event". as long as the perverted hypothesis of creationism is in existence, kids will always be brain-washed by it. nowadays, you hear creationism everywhere. it is impossible to keep a child away from that. this is why, as atheists, we are always affected by religion, creationists, and theists.
Did you just make up those statistics??? by the people I know round here it'd more likely be 10% would vote for a gay president and 1% for an atheist. Though I do live in the bible belt right now.
everyone click on the link
i agree with it, but its the part where they say a leader SHOULD have god's assistance that tick me off. it's kind of contradictory, since the country itself was FOUND by men whom agree that religion should never, in any form, be associated with politics. and yet, george bush himself stated that he believed god was by his side helping him with his job. and i can't help but notice that almost all major wars are based on religion. a nice quote from hitler:
"And hence today, I believe I am acting apon the will of the Almighty."
nice link. i clicked. tell me if the first vid actually shows xD
Infants are wholly and completely dependant on their caregivers (usually parents). As such, they quickly begin to view their CGs as "s(he) who has god-like powers" and begin to revere them as such. When this god-like person later explains to the child that they, themselves, fear god, the child makes the connection that this parent-god is in fear of this all-powerful god and therefore, that all-powerful god must be incredibly powerful. This is reinforced with admonitions against angering the big god or really bad things will happen to you.
It's near impossible to beat a racket like that with rational and logical thinking because the rational and logical mind is not developed until many years after the irrational and illogical has been firmly implanted.
It seems unlikely that we will overcome this mass brainwashing any time soon. Perhaps not even before we destroy our planet's ability to support our species. Too bad. We had a good thing going.
I have had a similar experience in that I was baptised Catholic, not forced to go to church regularly, and embraced logic and reason at an early age.
But people your making it sound like no child in the world can possibly believe anything other than what they were raised to believe. God was being pushed on me at a very young age and I hav like 50 bibles and shit up in the attic from what my granddad gave me over the year. And I stopped believing in god shortly after my first holy communion and if I could do it then it isn't really that hard for anyone else to do it. You need to brainwash a child into that shit because if you tell a 16 year old who has never heard of god in their life that a carpenter walked on water and turned water into wine theyd think your fucking retarded. So they just pretty much force a kid into believing it, some do some don't.
This is distinctly different from not allowing religion.
Bush speaking about his faith and "God" would not be an offense to the founding fathers. But a few things Mr. Bush has done probably would be.
My wife, on the other hand, was thouroughly indoctrinated and even spent a few summers during college smuggling bibles into the Soviet Union to help "save" the heathens. Boy, was she brainwashed!
After being asked to leave her church because she divorced her dickhead first husband, she started thinking that it wasn't all that. She'd never heard of Jesus rejecting someone, so it didn't add up and she started asking questions. Then I came into her life and, along with me, logic and reason. She's on our side now.
So, it can work both ways although I'm dubious that my wife's situation is very common. There are also cases where too much indoctrination leads to total rejection (my wife - and you - may be a variant of this type).
I don't think it's impossible for people to change from their upbringing. I just think it fits a bell curve. Those in the margins are more restless or inquisitive than those in the comfy middle.
Most people need and/or want the security and freedom of having someone else tell them what to do and how to think because they are not comfortable that they can do it for themselves. It removes alot of effort if someone else already has all the answers and they don't have to work it through for themselves.
This is why our society (and democracy as our founding fathers conceived it) will not last. Politicians (and their corporate puppeteers) have learned from religion and history that if you can dumb-down the populace, you can manipulate and control them. We have the illusion of controlling our "elected" officials, but we don't really pull the strings.
@: P00LTOY also
In Thom Hartmann's book, "What Would Jefferson do?", Benjamin Franklin is quoted:
"I have found Christian dogma unintelligible. Early in life I absented myself from Christian assemblies." Franklin goes on to say that by the age of 15, he also doubted Christian teachings.
Hartmann also points out that Washington himself had "never, on any occasion, said a word to the public which showed a belief in the Christian religion".
but i believe in god or atleast something good.. i just hope when i die,
my soul will go some where happy because
living now is so very depressing and unhappy, but i try to make the best of it.
and the only reason why the world is so shitty because people WANT it to be like that, all people see is the negative shit in their lives not the good.
thats why so many turn to drugs and alcohol cause their life "soo bad"
thats why god made you have a mind to think for yourselves believe what you want
but when you die you'll end up with either one
god, or the devil, or even limbo.
just do nice things for people even though they prolly wont return the favor but hey, doesnt it make you feel good afterwards?..
p.s i dont think this post made any sense but it did to me ha.
Help me understand this:
You don't think your post made any sense, but it did to you?
Is that an oxymoron or a quote from George W?
well i meant that cause its hard for me to explain things..
and yes, are their other reasons why they turn to drugs and alcohol?
majority of them is because they were abused as a child and the substance makes them feel "wanted"
thats what happened to me.
As for the abuse, I found that several years of therapy helped to address the abuse I encountered as a child and teenager.
BTW, religious indoctrination is a form of abuse, isn't it?
hey im not pushing anything on anyone i just wish people would kinda think about others opinions.
Also people I have found to be the least accepting of other beliefs are the ones that dont think about their own, they go "He doesn't believe what my priest once said, he's a retard" the ppl that bother thinking about it go "He doesn't believe what my priest said, he has a slightly different view than me, I really don't care"
i believe things on my own, not because someone told me too..
Besides if god does exist then he should at least respect us sticking with our beliefs, even if they weren't his beliefs, and not everyone believes in Christianity, Judaism, or whatever religion you are and so do you think that everyone not in YOUR religion is going to hell? or just those that don't believe in god? Either way the only people that should go to hell are the one's that fuck up other peoples lives, the murderor's, rapists, etc... not just those people that don't believe god.
in that case, would god really let you escape that, even thought yu are believing out of fear?
god, im assuming, is looking for TRUE believers, not ones that would say they believe, or even believe, out of pure fear. god would more likely respect the atheists for being honest and not be indoctrinated by fake faith. us, burn in hell? more like you cowards who believe out of pure fear
and, your entire argument is based on the assumtion and FALSEHOOD that god exists, and that he is still around to give a shit. just like the one i've talked to earlier, you are using god's name in vain by using it as a threat. would he really send you to heaven for saying that?
for example, history. whenever theres a gap, you say that is proof of god. well, there will always be gaps, however small. and just because there is a gap, it does not prove that there really is a god acting in, making the gap. most foolish theists just assume this, making "god" the default.
another example would be evolution. they compare evolution with chance. they say, "look at this marvelous animal. look at the eyes, so sharp and keen. could this have happened by chance?"
well, this is all on the assumption that the eye came to be BY chance, and also the assumption that the percentage not filled in by chance is, by default, god. for example, lets say theres 1% chance of the eye randomly being formed. they falsely assume the other 99% MUST be god
now, evolution, the EYE, isn't by chance. it is like a mountain, with one side slowly inclining, the other side a cliff. it is very unlikely for a person to jump right on top of the cliff, however on the other side they can SLOWLY get on top. evolution is the same thing. it didn't just happen by chance. it happened graduately, every piece over 95% likely. it's the same thing as breeding dogs.
so, if they would like to assume that evolution is complete chance, all at once, not in graduate stages, fine. they immediately say that its proof of intellegent design. i will say this again. intellegent design isn't the default. there are probably countless ways we could have existed without the need of intellegent design.
now, the biggest flaw of the intellegent design arguement, is that if the mere eye is so complicated that it MUST have been created by a greater being, that would make that being (god) even more complicated. therefore, according to the same logic as the arguement of intellegent design, that being (god) MUST have been created. got anything else to say? i will gladly hear it and crush it.
you clearly have no idea what you're talking about, sungirl. i disrespect all theists, because they follow their beliefs blindly, without proof. faith is nothing but bullshit, all it is, is a hallucination they entangle themselves into. it is obviously false, yet they prefer to be indulged in the illusion in order to live life hapily. whats so wrong aboutthe world without a god? are you afraid of seeing nothing to live for? well?
Think about this, if a mother only had a child so that she could torture it and kill it, should she deserve punishment? Yes, the child may not have existed without her but it was being tortured so it would be better not to have existed. Lets pretend there is a god then god is our parent and is torturing us for as long as the human race lives. So why are we meant to worship god who tortures us when we send people that murder their own kids to prison?? there is no difference between them. That is why god shouldn't be worshiped.
Like god created this world then fucked off.
Anyway, you shouldn't outright say there is no god. I say there could or couldn't, though if there is then I make out that he's really bad, so it's either nothing or a douche. Ahh no, I called god a douche, I'm gunna burn in hell!!
Do you mean he still shouldnt be worshiped? not should.
All the god bashing posts in this thread could have been substituted for one sentence stating "I dont believe in God for my own reasons".
But atheists cant stop there can they? They have to denigrate religious ppl and their beliefs. People like you always point to the religious ones as intolerant but take a look in the mirror.
It's no longer a one way street. For every atheist that bemoans the common religious view that non-believer are doomed to damnation, theres a religious person that has to suffer at the hands of another "I opened my eyes and saw the bullshit now let me tell the world!" atheist who speaks down to religious ppl as if they are somehow superior and have to tell the whole fucken world about it.
Rant over.
just to get you started, go google "the big bang theory" i don't expect you to understand it. you might ask, who created the big bang? well, for one, it doesn't necessarily have to have been created. it can simply already have been there. if you think it MUST have been created, then you have a lack of imagination. because, according to the laws of thermodynamics, energy cannot be created. coal is energy. everything is a form of energy. if you say that the laws of thermodynamics is wrong, boy, you would be dead right now. if the laws of thermodynamics does not exist, none of us could live.
now, lets say that SOMEHOW the universe WAS created. and let's say science can't explain how. what the FUCK makes god the default for something that can't yet be answered? well?
now, you people believe in a god who is omnipotent, omniscient, the purity of goodness, etc...that would be the definition of god. otherwise, it wouldn't be a god.
now, ill let you in on a little secret. for you dumbass idiots who can't see it, theres a damn paradox in that.
first off, the laws of science disallow omnipotence and omniscience. im sure you're not conviced by that, since he's "god" and all.
now, lets say that because hes omniscient, he knows exactly how hes going to intervene to change the world into its final stage using his omnipotence. but wouldn't that mean god is unable to change the "future", which he FORSAW using his omniscience? in other words, he can't change his own actions? wouldn't that mean he's NOT omnipotent? so, what if he COULD change the "future" he forsaw. wouldn't that mean what he forsaw earlier was invalid, and therefore proving hes not omniscient.
in this sense, "god" can only be omniscient OR omnipotent. however, a being with only ONE of these qualities isn't even defined as a "god". so you are left with two options.
option one, assuming god is only omnipotent. This would mean he created everything, but has morals as valid as you or me. he cannot see the future, nor predict what we will do. he cannot see every little dark thought we have. this means, he has no control over us. if he did, we are just dolls, without a choice. so why not just go kill yourself now?
now, option two, assuming god is omniscient. this is even worse. this would mean he did not create the universe, and cannot defy laws of gravity, thermodynamics, and etc. in this sense, he wouldn't even be omniscient, since it goes against science and the laws. this would also mean he would have to be created AFTER the creation of the universe, which invalids his very creation, due to the laws.
so, since option 1 pretty much disables god's ability to direct the world or affect us with "faith", this either means god is waiting for a time to just come down and show his face, and admit he can't know a thing.
or, he created the universe and retired after that, just existing without a goal or point, all the way through eternity.
or, there is no god, and all this is talk about the almighty is bullsh*t.
you should also read this entire debate before speaking,ikeBro. i have already fully explained why i will not just allow religion to exist. ill copy and paste, you can read it from here.
okay, this is directed towards atheists, and theists. this part is for those who think that we should not attack religion, simply because it doesn't interfere with us. i have to respectfulyl disagree.
religion, especially christianity, limits our very RIGHT as atheists. it was not recorded, however, in an interview, george bush stated himself that he did not consider atheists to be patriotic or citizens of america. while over 95 percent of the population would vote for homosexuals or blacks, only 49% would vote for atheists as president.
in this world, especially in america, atheists are muchly hated, and are treated as badly as blacks 50 years ago. Many educated personnel on the american counsil had to fake their beliefs in order to be elected. Considering america was founded by men stating that religion should never mix with politics, this country has become a disgrace to it's founders.
from the crusades to modern day racism against atheism, i can honestly say, religion has always been, and always will be, for as long as it exists, an interferance to the proper education of science, and according to your statement, your life. you may not notice it, but the older you get, the more you realise, how much religion has taken away from you. even though religion was taken out of the school education system, there are always presentations on the subject from many churches, and the kids ranging from kindergarden to high school are forced to listen. those kids know only to obey the teacher. they don't even know about religious freedom. to them, they have no choice. it is the same as forcing a child to become christian/morman/whatever religion.
i have experienced this myself when i was 8. i did not know i could leave at any time. and at the time, if a student tried to leave, the teacher would not allow it. i remember the great impact the bible they gave us and the words they gave us had on us. children that young, who does not even have the generally accepted, by science, and by the education system, the big bang theory, already being fed religion. why are children learning a hypothesis, or even a lie, before learning what is accepted by the scientific and educational community as a fact and truth?
those children are easily convinced and manipulated through complicated and hard-to-comprehend words of religion, and, due to human curiosity, every child is bound to have thought of the question, "how did we exist."
most parents would simply say, "you are too young", and leave the kids wondering. how grateful would the kids be, after all that time, to learn what they thought was "the truth"? they wouldn't even understand what a religion was. they'd think that it is the truth. once a child learns something, it is very difficult to change their minds. this is how religion is spread. once you tell a child, who wants nothing more than happiness, and to have fun, that by believing in god they will be forevermore happy, how will you ever convince them otherwise?
how is it that religion has ever been removed from schools? all of what i have written clearly shows, even though it is out of the official system, it is still part of the unofficial one, as a "school event". as long as the perverted hypothesis of creationism is in existence, kids will always be brain-washed by it. nowadays, you hear creationism everywhere. it is impossible to keep a child away from that. this is why, as atheists, we are always affected by religion, creationists, and theists.
now, i have another to add. you say we SHOULDN'T interfere with their beliefs,because they never do the same to us? well, not only does the above prove taht wrong, theres also something else. the CRUSADES. they decided that anyone who didn't believe in god was evil and deserve to be punished, and murdered them all in inhuman ways. not only does this prove my point, but does this not go against their own religion? thou shall not kill. well, they just sinned, huh? lets say it was GOD's will. okay, then god just sinned. he's evil. very much like a god, huh? and isn't it supposed to be god's job to judge who is evil? how is it that they know it is THEM that's the evil ones? why are they doing god's work? would you say that they did the right thing? if you do, then YOU are evil.
if you read the old testament, god supported killing one's own children, the killing of homosexuals (which is his OWN CREATION, so did so called GOD make a mistake?), and the ownership of women to men. not only is this ungodly, full of evil, but it goes against our very morals and our sense of good and evil.
if believing in god means turning you into a heartless beast, killing your own children, turning yourself into a grand version of hitler, then i would rather die, that worship such a being. there are much more to be said, you should go up and read what i said earlier. most of your arguements for god is pitiful, to say the very least, if not delusional. think twice before believing in a being of such cruelty, dogma, insignificance to the developement of the modern world.
The ultimate god, the ultimate source of power in the universe from which we come is not the one messing with us all the time. The ultimate God is at the core of our being as well as the core of the universe.
I'm talking about the creature just above our consciousness who knows about us when we don't know about him. He can see us, and follow our movements, but we can't see him, not even imagine him.
But he's not god, he's just the kid with the ant farm.
sungirl, come up with REAL arguments, other than ones based on personal feelings or assumtions and hypothesis. you keep saying "what will happen once you die and face god?", when it cannot be backed up by ANY physical evidence that god even exists. fom that, it is easily acknowledgable that all you say is based on what you FEEL, what you WANT, and what others SAY.
when you conduct this debate with evidence and proper reasoning, i will be glad to prove you wrong, other than that, you might as well go read a book first and get your ground first.
now, something else to add. i always tell people this, that religious people are idiots. this can actually be proven. in a survey, it is found that the average iq of atheists and agnostics are higher than those of the religious. and im not talking just 1 or 2 points. china is a sure example. compared to the average iq of 100 of the highly religious america, china, one of the most non-religious countries you will ever find, has an average iq of 120. this can be applied. you see america? they've barely done anything in the past 50 years. china, without religion, WITH the iron fist, has pulled themselves up from what seemed to be like the dark ages, all the way up to near america's standards. if people were religious, this would not have happened, as they would "respect" the rights of people (which is say is overexaggerated), donate all their money to church, which is wasted on the uneducated and the disabled, who, chances are, will not have contributions to societly either way. if you're already developed, thats your choice to waste your money. it just means your country will barely develope. china just forgets those people. thats why they have become so strong is such a short amount of time. so, sungirl, think before arguing.
the god of the old testament (dont complain ,it IS the work of "god"'s faithful followers) is supportive of the killing of one's kids, the ownership of women to men, and the killing of atheists and homosexuals (which is his own creation. did he make a mistake?)
so now, they made up a new god in the "new" testament, and got rid of those things. if you read the bible properly, you will see many more contradictions.
also, when they first invented god, they LITERALLY said that god was in the skies. so when man decided to look up, they changed it to ABOVE the skies. when we discovered space, they decided it to be INVISIBLE and UNTOUCHABLE. in this case, god has no mass or space. the only way for him to exist now is as a ENERGY. which means he can be found in a lump of coal. it means we can PHYSICALLY CONVERT god into fuel. thats a nice ending to it, huh?
so, sungirl, read all of what i wrote in that last few days, THEN try and argue. YOu tell ME who's changing the story. scientists ADD to the story, nothing is changed. they ADD more, because more proof is popping up, SUPPORTING the big bang theory. you theists CHANGE your story, because more proof pops up AGAINST god. so who's the one playing dirty, who are the idiots, and WHO are the ones that has NO PROOF?!
btw, you need to work on your english. you made some SERIOUS grammatrical mistakes.
now, to the theists: if all the religious claims in the world are true, there would be over a thousand gods by now. that defies all of the religions i know of. why would a supreme being, even BOTHER to listen to one's prayers? it's not like he will grant them. there are people who pray to be able to harm others. will god grant that? and besides, god has a little "devine plan". im sure that devine plan doesn't involve every single one of your prayers. ever notice that many of your prayers dont' get answered, and the ones that do are by luck? so what then? many theists will just say, "oo its god's will". well, since hes not gunna answer your prayers, why not just fucked the praying and jsut get to the "god's will"?
and all of the above is based on the false hypothesis that GOD exists. if you read my earlier posts, you will notice that it is near impossible to be a god, and that the only reason its not completely impossible is because of all theextra bullshit you people add in.
"now, i have another to add. you say we SHOULDN'T interfere with their beliefs,because they never do the same to us? well, not only does the above prove taht wrong, theres also something else. the CRUSADES. they decided that anyone who didn't believe in god was evil and deserve to be punished, and murdered them all in inhuman ways. not only does this prove my point, but does this not go against their own religion?"
So going on this reasoning, children of murderers and rapists are just as guilty as their murdering parents? My granddad went to prison for theft. Should I be chucked in the slammer as well? Does this then make all parents guilty? Obviously not, so why then tar all the religious people with the same brush?
Personally I don't really believe in god. But fuck me if I'll stand around and let ignorant posters like the above rap off their poorly-informed misconceptions without being challenged.
I'll say it once again: People should be free to follow whatever religion they choose. Places where this isn't allowed are usually fascist regimes.
I also notice with just a little bit of mirth how it's Christianity that gets ripped on. Why not mention the Jews fellas? Scared of being labeled a bigot?
they also try to convert us atheists. that does not justify us interefering, but trying to spread knowledge with proof isn't a crime.
now, go look up, and you will find things that they have DONE to us, and DO to us RIGHT NOW. ill copy it for you, in fact.
"
okay, this is directed towards atheists, and theists. this part is for those who think that we should not attack religion, simply because it doesn't interfere with us. i have to respectfulyl disagree.
religion, especially christianity, limits our very RIGHT as atheists. it was not recorded, however, in an interview, george bush stated himself that he did not consider atheists to be patriotic or citizens of america. while over 95 percent of the population would vote for homosexuals or blacks, only 49% would vote for atheists as president.
in this world, especially in america, atheists are muchly hated, and are treated as badly as blacks 50 years ago. Many educated personnel on the american counsil had to fake their beliefs in order to be elected. Considering america was founded by men stating that religion should never mix with politics, this country has become a disgrace to it's founders.
from the crusades to modern day racism against atheism, i can honestly say, religion has always been, and always will be, for as long as it exists, an interferance to the proper education of science, and according to your statement, your life. you may not notice it, but the older you get, the more you realise, how much religion has taken away from you. even though religion was taken out of the school education system, there are always presentations on the subject from many churches, and the kids ranging from kindergarden to high school are forced to listen. those kids know only to obey the teacher. they don't even know about religious freedom. to them, they have no choice. it is the same as forcing a child to become christian/morman/whatever religion.
i have experienced this myself when i was 8. i did not know i could leave at any time. and at the time, if a student tried to leave, the teacher would not allow it. i remember the great impact the bible they gave us and the words they gave us had on us. children that young, who does not even have the generally accepted, by science, and by the education system, the big bang theory, already being fed religion. why are children learning a hypothesis, or even a lie, before learning what is accepted by the scientific and educational community as a fact and truth?
those children are easily convinced and manipulated through complicated and hard-to-comprehend words of religion, and, due to human curiosity, every child is bound to have thought of the question, "how did we exist."
most parents would simply say, "you are too young", and leave the kids wondering. how grateful would the kids be, after all that time, to learn what they thought was "the truth"? they wouldn't even understand what a religion was. they'd think that it is the truth. once a child learns something, it is very difficult to change their minds. this is how religion is spread. once you tell a child, who wants nothing more than happiness, and to have fun, that by believing in god they will be forevermore happy, how will you ever convince them otherwise?
how is it that religion has ever been removed from schools? all of what i have written clearly shows, even though it is out of the official system, it is still part of the unofficial one, as a "school event". as long as the perverted hypothesis of creationism is in existence, kids will always be brain-washed by it. nowadays, you hear creationism everywhere. it is impossible to keep a child away from that. this is why, as atheists, we are always affected by religion, creationists, and theists.
"
i realise that you are atheist. im not arguing with you, i am merely proving that my intention is not revenge. they KILLED us for not believing. we just want them to look at some logic. i have no intention of murdering them because theior ancestors did the same. freedom of speech is a right, no? what they have done to atheists in the past is simply another way i am against religion, and not in the sense of revenge. its because religion has caused countless wars and deaths. i will repeat, i said what you have quoted of me, only to prove to sungirl that religion DOES interfere with us. if she had read what i quoted above (the big long one), she would not have even said it. again, i don't want to argue you, and i don't fee like there is anything to argue about. im just showing you what my intention was, trying to avoid a misunderstanding.
like you said, i don't think a child should be punished for the parent's doing. that is absurd and wrong. however, going slightly off topic, that IS what theists have done to atheists in the past. again, i said the last sentence just to show you what religion has done, not using it as an excuse of revenge. besides, arguement and persuasion for understanding of provable facts isn't revenge.
and just to make it clear, i dun wanna argue ;D, and i see nothing to argue about. =)i really don't wanna cause a misunderstanding >.
debates are my forte, and ignorance just pisses me off xD
i write more than i usually would, when the person arguing comes up with such weak arguements, complete dogma, that i actually get a bit pissed off and annoyed by them. if they can at least include a tiny bit of logic, i would gladly have a NICE debate. when i saw sungirl's arguements, i almost fainted out of disappointment....
im sure i have said this already, but this book is a must, for an atheist. "The God Delusion" by Richard Dawkins. he contradicts all of the major christian arguements for god (which is pretty much the same for other religions). i was about to put the link for the ebook(the real book is $20 CAN at chapters), but the page was deleted for copyright violations. i have the ebook, and i also bought the book. i must say, if a christian can read the book completely, and fully understand every word, and still does not change religion, then he/she is truely hopeless and narrow minded.
besides, im still in school and this is seriously improving my writing skills =D, but of course, this is only a "bonus". if richard dawkins can't do the job with his book, then i will write one myself once i've settled down. =)
well, sorry. =)
xD it was fun thou....:P
Anyway your posts are very long, proves a point and has like all the info there but if someone doesn't want to listen to logic then they wulda gave up reading them on like the first paragraph.
Though I do agree with like everything you posted there.
or, if you take INTO ACCOUNT the survey done on the intellegence of theists, maybe not so much ;P
theres another dumbass that need our help.
http://isitnormal.com/story/5873/#new-comment-form
come along and enjoy the conversion =D
The world is not a simple place, in case you haven't noticed.
Why isn't it possible that God and Jesus are real, exactly as the Bible says they are? The Old Testament God isn't discreet about his anger or his vengeful behavior...he kills people outright! He never claims to be a universal benefactor! In the New Testament Jesus introduces unconditional love and forgiveness; it really is quite a paradox.
I decided to ditch the reasoning you outlined above and become a humble worshipper of Christ, and not because I want to be better than you or rest on my laurels or anything like that. I do so because the way this mysterious and awesome world we inhabit works is not as simple as a basic 'if/then' statement.
people did,
and if that paragraph is really what you belive then
why waste your time with life
i see you are very upset about our planetary situation
there is much i could say but i will summarize it like this
the idea of God is real. but it is not correct as it is portrayed by most
God is the Source of All Things. and we (you, me, all life-forms) are fragments of this "God" idea.
therefore, you are a fragment of God.
what happens is, FREE WILL IS INVIOLATE. and that is universally accepted.
but don't worry. keep on knowing what's right, and keep on being absolutely critical of our current planetary situation.
very soon, our entire civilization will be re-structured, and humans lie you will be the ones showing the others what is necessary for achieving balance.
all this is the absolute nature of the Creation.
not initially believe there is a god. If there is the God as in Ge of the Holy Bible, then he is a wrathful prick. 'Do not muder'?! Fair enough, but God drowned all those people and animals in the Red Sea. Yes, this was more or less with justice, but he still killed them, so he's just as bad. And why was oh-so perfect Man made the dominant species and allowed to kill the other animals? Why were there only two? A man and a woman? Why, was the human race called that of MAN with men always more powerful?!
Okay this is off-track a bit, but, if God wanted a good Earth... He did not create 'Man' in such a perfect image.
Look what has happened.
most people blame the devil for the mess the world is in. i don't believe in the devil, but i don't blame god. i blame man.
god did not make us a bunch of robots. he pretty much sits back and lets us do our own thing, and face the consequences of our actions. why don't he step in and set things right? well, i don't know, but someday he might, and a lot of people won't like it if and when he does. maybe he is just waiting to see if we will ever work out our own stupid problems. who knows?
maybe he is too busy running the rest of the universe to worry about what is going on down here on this flyspeck of a planet. maybe it is up to us to work out our own differences and problems, instead of blaming him for everything, like he is some divine scapegoat. (that is what a lot of you use the devil for too. like blame anyone except yourself when you fuck up, right?)
http://www.facebook.com/home.php#/video/video.php?v=155315264765&ref=nf