Can you date a girl with a slutty past?

Last summer my friend had a huge summer party it was an out door fire turned end of the night basement party. One of the girls there was hooking up with one of my buddies not dating they had just been hooking up at that time. It was really late mostly dark in the basement and those two were sharing a futon in the corner of the basement with another dude. Everyone heard that they were hooking up but when two of our other friends who don’t really drink much went to leave around 4 in the morning as they were going out the bulkhead she was on top riding the one guy she was hooking up with and was leaned over giving the other kid a hand job they said they saw a good look at it and it was clear what they were doing and as they got to the door the one getting a hand job flipped the blankets over himself really fast but before that the blankets were completely off All of them. The two that saw aren’t people who would lie at all and like I said we all heard and knew someone was hooking up anyways. But my problem is recently we started talking I really like her but knowing that about her really turns me off and idk what to do.

Voting Results
59% Normal
Based on 17 votes (10 yes)
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 16 )
  • donteatstuffoffthesidewalk

    beats a girl with a slutty present

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • GeekyGold

    I wouldn’t care, to me what is more important is someone’s loyalty. If she was known to cheat during a relationship then yeah, be wary. But she is single so she can do whatever she wants. Also, just because she was caught with those two, doesn’t mean she has a slutty past. That’s just slut shaming dude. Threesomes are a thing just because someone is a part of it doesn’t mean they are a slut.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • asdfgh0987

    As someone who has hooked up outside of a monogamous relationship, you can be a "slut" and like hookups and desire monogamy with the right person. I slept with maybe 30 people before I met my girlfriend. I've slept with one person since we started dating, and it's her. Just because something is one way one time doesn't mean it'll always be that way.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • SwickDinging

    It seems ridiculous that you wouldn't pursue something with a person that you really like just because someone told you they saw them having a 3 way. But it sounds like it really bothers you for some reason, so maybe it is best to just stay away.

    I have learned to be very cautious about gossip. Unless you saw something with your own eyes I would always consider it to be possibly untrue, exaggerated, and definitely only half the story. You have no idea what really happened, or why it happened. Even if it did happen how they said, for all you know she could have been drugged, she could have been going through a bad time, she could have been forced/blackmailed, she could be being abused by her dad and not known how to cope, she could be secretly gay and desperate to hide it, she could just be super horny. Who knows. Only she really knows the full story.

    I definitely wouldn't use secondhand information as a reason not to be with someone who I really liked, without at least asking them for their side of the story first.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • RoseIsabella

    Sounds a little too recent to be the past.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Somenormie

    Not normal, I would recommend that you don't date someone who is or was associated with sluts.

    Date them at your own risk.

    I am no means condoning that you do this.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Bazinga

    Everyone lies about sex; it's only human nature. So is hooking up. Look for qualities of good judgement that the girl has in other areas.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • No.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • FromTheSouthWeirdMan

    I am more attracted to the slutty girls personally. I find them more fun, more adventurous. I've dated those proper girls, the christian type. And alot of them are just plain boring. They say no to everything. If good sex is important to you then try it out. If it doesnt work who gives a shit, you had good sex with her. You cant lose.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • jimmyneutron69

    Imma give you the fastest way to figure it out yourself if you're ok with it, ready? If she's as slutty as you say just sleep with her. If you still feel the same love after then go for it. If your feelings are gone you're just horny or if your feelings of doubt are still there then it's probably not the right person for you. done

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • randypete

    yes I love sluts

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Tommythecaty

    Yep, my past is no different so why not. Some of the best chicks you’ll meet have pasts like that.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • ellnell

    If that turns you off you can't like her that much. You should see someone else.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Boojum

    If you're too much of a prude to accept what she did, then it's pretty damn obvious you should keep your distance. And the same applies if, as I suspect, you're at that age when what others think and say about you and the girls you're dating is hugely important to you due to your basic insecurity.

    What a person does once while under the influence of alcohol does not define who that person truly is. However, you calling a girl a slut because of an event you only know about because of what others claimed they saw makes it pretty damn clear what sort of a person you are.

    I strongly suspect she'll be better off if you're not any more a part of her life than you already are.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • have_a_good_day

    maybe you feel intimidated and inadequate in regards to da size of yo dick. you know she a hoe and feel scared coz yo dick don't measure up to others and subconsciously it makes you feel like you can't satisfy dat pussy

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • olderdude-xx

    Why not? People change... She may well be looking for a better life - and you can offer her that.

    Comment Hidden ( show )