I got dumped… for a cat

I absolutely love pets, but I am extremely allergic to cats. I once ended up in the emergency room because of a cat as my throat was closing up.

I have been in a wonderful relationship since 2019 with a girl that I love and care for dearly. She recently brought home a kitten that was given to her by a colleague at work. I immediately begged her to give it back and told her that we can have a dog or any other pet as long as it isn’t one that I am extremely allergic to. She kept insisting that I should consider taking meds so she could keep the cat and I refused. It ended with me getting dumped over the cat…

I thought relationships are all about mutual care, right?

Voting Results
31% Normal
Based on 36 votes (11 yes)
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 49 )
  • Find a new girlfriend.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • RoseIsabella

      I wish I could give this 100 thumbs up! 👍🏻

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • Its an ordinary comment. Doesn't deserve 100 upvotes.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
    • RoseIsabella

      Yes!

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • SwickDinging

    She did you a favour.

    This wasn't about the cat, it was about her not prioritising your needs. If it hadn't been the cat then something else would have come up eventually where she powered ahead with something she wanted in spite of it causing some kind of pain or difficulty to you. It me and that you aren't right for each other.

    She has freed you. Now you can find someone who actually really cares about you.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Umm.. Okay. If it were a cat she's had already before she met you then I would say that's normal, honestly. Getting rid of a pet for a partner is like throwing your kid away for a partner albeit yeah, unfortunately some parents do that... But most wouldn't.
    This is a differnt situation entirely though. You guys live together I assume? It's very bad to decide to adopt a pet you know your partner is severely allergic to. Maybe she wants a cat really badly, I dont know, but obviously she should've discussed it with you first. I know that there's allergy pills and even shots, and I know there's plenty of people with terrible cat allergies who was able to get a cat and never experience any issues after treating their allergy. I don't know if you've ever tried that? But if not that's kind of something you'd propose to the person you live with -before- just bringing the cat home. So maybe it's for the best then. Seems you guys had some communication issues.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Lusty-Argonian

    I get wanting a cat buy I wouldn't throw my partner away for one. If the cat was there first than sorry man not happening. But to get a pet knowing full well they are allergic is fd up.

    One guy I dated poisoned some food he made me once cause he didn't beilive I was allergic. Then got pissed at me when I couldn't even finish one serving of it because I was busy projectile vomiting in the toilet just trying to breath to stay alive.

    People who can't be bothered to take your allergies seriously are not worth your tears.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • SkullsNRoses

      That’s absolutely awful of your ex to do, I hope he wakes up to bird shit all over his car everyday.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • RoseIsabella

    If it's any consolation I once met a guy while I was working at Petsmart a long time ago who confided in me that he was thinking about dumping his girlfriend, because she wanted him to keep his dog outside in the backyard... and yes, I offered that guy moral support, because that woman may have been his girlfriend, but his Akita, she, was his baby. I didn't think it was a tragedy that he loved his dog more than some woman, because he shouldn't have to change for some woman, and the right woman for him will love his dog just as much as he does, and the right woman for you will not be a cat lady. I know you're going through a difficult time, but it's wouldn't be fair to either of you if ya'll stayed together, because you can't be yourselves, and someone would be forced to give up something they love deeply, or else someone else would be forced to give up their health. Staying together would be a lose/lose situation.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • olderdude-xx

    Unfortunately, this is all to common. It is the extremely rare woman who is willing to give up their cat for a man; and many are not understanding of severe allergies and minimize in their mind how significant the issue is for anyone who has more than a very minor allergy to cats.

    I too am severely allergic to cats and understand exactly your situation. Sustained exposure to cats beyond a few minutes could kill me. Even a few minutes exposure often affects me badly for days. I often react to cat dander on clothing as well.

    What most people do not understand is that there are no medications for severe allergies that are safe to take for more than a few days - and those medications have significant and dangerous side effects.

    I'm going to warn you that you have an uphill battle as my personal (and very painful) experience is most women with cats do not understand how significant these kinds of allergies can be; and lie about having cats even if you ask them up front on the phone/Skype/etc.

    I know this as I listed that I had extreme allergies to cats in all of my dating profiles on the many dating sites I used over about 15 years.

    I also then asked during our initial conversation if they had cats as I was highly allergic to them. Yet about half of the people I met in person had cats - and I very often would start to react to the cat dander on their clothing... too which their common response was... I didn't know that you were that allergic cats, or my cat. Sometimes they would say that they had an "allergen free" cat - which is a reduced allergen cat and not allergen free cat in actuality; and they were totally stunned at my allergic reactions. I do tell them I asked if they had cats... not if they had an "allergen free" cat.

    I even had an ER Nurse pull the "allergen free" cat trick on me by inviting me to her house for Thanksgiving with her family, hiding the cat, and I reacted so badly within a few minutes that I almost ended up in the emergency room (and it was days to recover).

    I wish you well with this... and encourage you to be explicit and upfront. Dating you is contingent on cat free - and even potentially cleaning their apartment or house with "anti-allergen" cleaners if their was a cat in it in the last decade (it usually takes about 10 years for cat dander to fade away).

    Drop anyone like a rock who lies to you...

    You will find some ladies who understand allergies and are willing to do what it takes if you are a decent gentleman.

    I note that it is possible to find a Lady who is willing to use "anti-allergen" laundry detergent on her cloths and ultimately give up her cat if you are the right guy... My wife did that (and we cleaned virtually all of her belongings with "anti-allergen" cleaners when she moved into my house.

    I wish you well with this,

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Thanks for the best, most spot on post in this entire thread. True words of wisdom!

      I am actually flabbergasted that the poll is currently at 50% (4y/4n). People are truly underestimating the severity of fatal allergies and to top if off it seems like a lot of people think it’s “normal” to choose a pet over a loved one. Relationships are all about caring for each other and we are better off without people who can’t even respect our fatal allergies. It seems like some people are naive, others are self centered and some are clueless.

      Only people like you and me know the true extent of our allergies.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • olderdude-xx

        Your welcome.

        I long ago got over how many woman would lie about having a cat... or living with someone who had a cat. Just know that a lot of them will lie about it.

        Anyway... the causal date ends instantly when I reacted to cat and they admitted they had lied to me about having one or living with one.

        If someone tells me that they lived with someone with a cat; then I tell them that they have to wear fresh laundered clothing when we meet - and that always worked. If it moved far enough along for overnights and trips I could either provide them with the special allergen laundry detergent or they provided clothing for me to wash for them (and keep at my house).

        Most ladies do not have cats... and any decent one will work with you on the allergen issue if they live with someone who does (their apartment or house is off limits for you), or if a previous apartment or house resident had a cat and the carpets, furniture, walls, etc. need cleaning with "anti-allergen" cleaners (I provided those cleaners and I split the cost of a carpet cleaning once).

        Be sure to carry Albuteral, an epi-pen, and prednisone in your car and luggage for emergencies. I've never used the epi-pen... but I have used everything else, multiple times.

        Go fourth and find a decent GF and other friends....

        Comment Hidden ( show )
    • Grunewald

      This.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Somenormie

    She is just selfish, caring about some cat than you.

    You should break up with her and find someone else.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • RoseIsabella

      She could also argue that OP is being selfish by refusing to take allergy medication.

      I myself would never date anyone who doesn't like cats, or is allergic, because I love cats even though I'm somewhat allergic myself. I choose to take medication, because my life is 100% better with feline companionship. I'd take my cat over having a boyfriend any day of the week. Unfortunately, OP had the misfortune of finding out that his ex-girlfriend is like me a little too late. Hopefully he will discuss these sort of matters with the women he dates in the future from the very beginning.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • olderdude-xx

        I disagree with this. There are no medications that stop severe allergies that are safe to take on a long term basis. Yes, you can shut down your immune system for short periods of time to recover, which leaves you at risk for other infections and problems - and the very medications that do this also produce other harmful side effects if used for more than a short time.

        I know all of this as I too am highly allergic to cats - and sustained cat exposure beyond a few minutes could actually kill me.

        I'd also like to point out that even if someone list in their dating profile that they are highly allergic to cats - many women with cats don't believe it ( or don't believe that they are allergic to their cat for some reason). Not only that if things look good and you end up talking that they will often lie about having cats when you ask them on the phone (or skype,etc now). I was on dating sites for almost 15 years with such a statement, and always asked if somoene had cats - and about half the Ladies I met in person turned out to have cats - and were amazed that I started to react just from the cat dander on their clothing. Been there, done that, far to many times to count.

        Edited to add: My wife gave up her cat to marry me; which is an extremely rare Lady.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • RoseIsabella

          I'm the last person who would ever hide my love of cats, and particularly my love of Siamese cats! To be completely honest I'm the sort of person who shouts her love of cats from the rooftops for all to hear. I would NEVER EVER give up having cats to marry anyone, because it would only guarantee me a life of misery, and perpetual resentment for my partner, and his allergies.

          My mother even once had a cat that I was so violently allergic to that I was starting to develop asthma like symptoms. My mom told me that someone stole the kitten, but I suspect she gave it away. I'm probably doing really well with my cat now, because I have pretty much quit smoking tobacco, and I recently learned from several articles online that Siamese cats are considered hypoallergenic, or at least significantly less allergic than the regular mongrel sort of cats. Honestly, I would very much like to see an allergist, and get the weekly shots to get rid of all of my allergies. I also wash my cat, and keep him indoors.

          For most animal lovers there's simply no reason to give up their favorite pet, or pets in order to be with someone who either doesn't like animals, or is allergic. I don't say any of this to be rude, or spiteful. I simply say it, because it's what holds most true to me in my heart. I have had zero interest in dating for the past few years, but when I used to date my first question has, is and always will be whether or not the person likes animals, specifically cats, and dogs. I've literally met a man in a drinking establishment who was interested in me, and after he told me that he didn't have pets, because he said animals are too much responsibility, and he's not really into animals I said, "well, it was nice meeting you. Goodbye, and good luck." I would never give up animals for anyone, it would such a waste be of my life!

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • SkullsNRoses

            I feel it wouldn’t be IIN without your love for cats, especially Andrew.

            Comment Hidden ( show )
              -
            • RoseIsabella

              Thanks!
              ♡☆♡☆♡☆♡☆♡☆
              Paws up to you!
              🤠👍🏻🐶🐱

              Comment Hidden ( show )
      • Grunewald

        She didn't know she would be getting a cat; her coworker gave it to her. It perhaps wasn't known that cat allergies even needed to be discussed until it happened - after all, you can't cover everything. The bf came first in this case.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • RoseIsabella

          I'm going to respectfully disagree, because maybe she thought he was fine with having a cat, and perhaps she was entirely unaware that he had allergies in the first place. There's no point in them staying together. God knows I would certainly be completely miserable in a relationship with a man where I could not have a feline companion. I don't think she should prioritize the man over the cat when to stay with the man would mean that she could never have a cat. At least they weren't married. I'd rather be single for the rest of my life than without a good Siamese bestfriend!

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • Grunewald

            Awww. I imagine you love cats so much that you couldn't keep your intention to have a cat secret from the person you're dating for very long. I so wish I wasn't allergic to cats.

            Comment Hidden ( show )
              -
            • RoseIsabella

              Yeah, I wear my love for cats, and dogs on my sleeve. 😊

              Comment Hidden ( show )
    • RoseIsabella

      P.S. She already broke up with him. I don't think she is selfish. In the long run I think she made the decision that will end up being best for all parties concerned. It would be unfair for her to be expected to give up her love of cats! Certainly there's someone better for OP out there in this big wide world!

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • 1WeirdGuy

    Shoulda ripped off its head and said u dont know what happened it was like this when you got home

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • megadriver

      Answered like an absolute psychopath... well done!

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • 1WeirdGuy

        I try

        Comment Hidden ( show )
    • bbrown95

      I hope this is a joke! The poor cat doesn't deserve to be punished because of this, he is just caught in the middle!

      Comment Hidden ( show )
    • MonteMetcalfe

      "How was I supposed to know it was in the garbage disposal when I turned it on?"

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • 1WeirdGuy

        "It must have jumped in the washer machine"

        "BUT U NEVER DO LAUNDRY!!!"

        Comment Hidden ( show )
    • 😂

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Jamie_Sulky

    dude she's not even worth it if she chooses a cat over you. You have an allergy. Thats like dating someone with a peanut allergy and constantly buying nut based foods and making them peanut butter sandwiches. its either cruelty or just dumbfuckery.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • RoseIsabella

      They're just not compatible with each other, because of his cat allergy, and her obvious love of cats. It doesn't mean that either of them is a bad person. It just happened that this serious issue of incompatibility didn't become known to either of them until the opportunity presented itself. I don't think this woman is a bad person for doing what was best for her, and her life with regard to feline companionship. The unfortunate, and sad thing here, the tragedy, is that this particular issue of incompatibility didn't present itself sooner.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Curiouskitten444

    Not normal. I am shocked.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • RoseIsabella

      So what is she supposed to do? Is she supposed to stay with this poor guy, and live a lie. Is she supposed to just forfeit all the joy, and happiness that cats can bring to her life? She's just not the right one for him is all.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • YE

    I'm not sure what it is, particularly, about cats that has an adverse effect on your health, is it the cat fur, the smell of cats, or their psychic powers?

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • RoseIsabella

      Cats do not have psychic powers that undermine anyone's health. What cats do have are certain proteins in their saliva that coupled with their dander happened to cause allergies in some people.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • YE

        Well explained, thanks. Never had any pets by the way.. hope you can understand.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
  • my_life_my_way

    Take control of the situation, let the cat go or just get rid of it and get your girl back

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • RoseIsabella

      No, that's dishonest.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • SkullsNRoses

    You’re right that relationships are about mutual care. Perhaps she subconsciously got the cat because she knew it would push you away and she wanted an excuse to end the relationship?

    Whatever the reasoning I’m sorry you’re in this situation, if my suggestion is right then she should have just been honest with you and even if I’m wrong her dumping you for a cat she’s had for a few weeks shows how she wasn’t a quality partner to begin with.

    Hopefully in time you will find a woman who you can raise some furless pets with.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • SudoHalt

    You dodged a bullet.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Tommythecaty

    Ah well that shows you what kind of character she really was. Meaning she would have fucked up the relationship either way at some point in the near future.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • RoseIsabella

      Not necessarily. I just think those two were a bad match.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • RoseIsabella

    I'm sorry that you are experiencing the pain of a breakup. I don't know how old ya'll are, but there's probably a lesson to be learned somewhere in here.

    I myself am a person who loves cats as well as an allergy sufferer. I take both Flonase, and Zyrtec for my allergies. To be completely honest I never date anyone who either doesn't like cats, or is allergic to cats, because I have a lovely 14 year old Siamese cat who is light of my life! When my cat passes away I fully intend to contact a reputable breeder, and get another Siamese kitten, or maybe two. For a long time I thought I had developed an immunity to my bestfriend, but I recently learned that Siamese cats are considered somewhat hypoallergenic. As far as dogs are concerned I can tell you off the top of my head that poodles are considered hypoallergenic.

    I would highly advise you to tell the women you date up front that you are highly allergic to cats, but unwilling to take allergy medication. I also think you should probably try to establish whether, or not a woman is a cat person before you get serious with her. It's not unheard of for a person to absolutely love animals, but not be in a position to have one as a pet so it's important that you establish whether, or not someone your interested in wants a cat in the future. Just because someone doesn't have a certain type of pet doesn't mean that they might not want that pet in the future. I would highly advise you to establish whether, or not someone is a catlover before you start dating even if the person doesn't have any cats.

    I know you feel bad that your girlfriend chose a kitten over you, but I'm sure she also feels bad that you were unwilling to take allergy medication. The way I see things is that this situation is a two way street.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • True, it’s partially my fault for not mentioning my allergy early on. It didn’t cross my mind that it was relevant as neither of us had any pets at the time.

      As for the medication: it wouldn’t be a long term solution for me, as my allergy is fatal, unlike the typical allergy that would just cause some irritation. I wouldn’t be able to sleep with the fear of never waking up again due to suffocation. I was told by the doctor when it happened that I would had been dead if I arrived 30 min later. It felt like breathing through a straw and I was the closest brush with death that I have experienced in my life.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • RoseIsabella

        I'm sorry to hear that your allergy is so serious. Hopefully you can find the right non-cat person with whom to share your life, and companionship! It's a good thing you found out about all of this before ya'll got much more serious.

        Comment Hidden ( show )