Is it normal to love two people?

I currently have a 5 year relationship with my boyfriend. However,when the pandemic started, I moved back to my hometown so basically we're in a long distance relationship. He's somewhat of a perfect boyfriend and he's been good to me all these years and I love him so much. Marriage for the both of us was kind of a sure thing.

Since moving back to my hometown, I met this guy who has the same situation as I do - a 5 year relationship and also his girlfriend is in another city. We ended up flirting since we pretty much hangout at the same spot almost thrice a week. Now, I'm a flirty girl but I don't usually take these guys seriously. I get a few guys flirt with me everytime but I get sick of them after a month so its really not a big deal. I just like the attention I guess?

So me and this guy ended up talking everyday and going on dates (nobody in our circle of friends know).
We promised to not cross any lines and just stick to flirting but one thing lead to another. We kissed, we had sex, we basically did everything under the description of cheating. That was the first 3 months of being together.

Now, it's been 6 months since the day I met him. I thought it was purely physical attraction. I thought it was the sex that kept me going to him but we stopped fucking months ago and I dont know... Being in the same space with him was enough to keep me happy. Spending time with him was like spending time with someone I knew all my life. He was so easy to be with, always gentle, always patient with me. Talking to him was enough. I didn't need the sex and the kisses anymore, I just needed to be with him. He told me he felt the same but neither of us wants to let go of our long term relationships.

We're planning to end things next month because we know its wrong. It took a lot of strength for us to decide and do the right thing but I don't know if I can take it. I know its the right thing to do but why can't I breathe when I think about not being with him. Now, my heart sinks when he mentions his girlfriend's name compared to months ago that I didn't even flinch nor cared.

Somebody tell me what to do or how to deal with this. I'm so confused. Why do I feel like this? I can't tell this to anyone since we kept it a secret from everybody and its so painful to think that after all of that we need to pretend that nothing happened. I need to pretend that I didn't love every inch of his being, his smile, his laugh and everything in between. I'm scared that what if we we're meant for each other and we'd be making the mistake of letting each other go. Or what if I'm just projecting my emotions unto him because it's been so long since I saw my boyfriend?

Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 11 )
  • darefu

    How would you feel if your boy friend just wrote this story?
    Cut the strings to the long distance bf, set him free if it's meant to be it will come back.
    Experience has shown me, three months is the magic time frame, then the heart adapts to love the one you're with.
    I would suggest a 4 to 6 months break from both. See if either rises to the top and important enough or does a third person enter the equation. If a third comes into the picture you're just not ready for marriage yet.

    Enjoy yourself but don't tie another down to rules you can't abide by or aren't ready for.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Bunnygirl25

      My boyfriend is a very good guy and I'm afraid that if I break up with him and everything wouldn't work out, I won't find another guy like him. I'm really selfish aren't I? I just can't do it. That first sentence you wrote broke my heart. Maybe it's safer to just forget about this and stick to the plan of pretending it didn't happen.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • darefu

        But it did happen, and all things have a way of coming back up when we least expect it.
        Has long distance guy been faithful to you? How do you know?
        Long distance sucks, how much longer do you plan on being separated from him?
        Monogamous relationships are built on trust, long distance can really screw it up.

        Neither screws around, you push the I believe button and nothing ever comes back to haunt you. Gold...

        One screws around and you find out, both sides suck, you for screwing around and you can never get that original trust back. The other person feels like shit because they most likely had opportunities but didn't partake, remaining faithful to one they trusted. Lose/lose

        You both screw around, most likely it will happen again, there's little if any trust of faithfulness. Good if you would like to be swingers after marriage. If you're thinking of monogamous marriage then this is probably not the one.

        Break it off with 5yr guy at least during separation. If it you get back together and it comes up later it's not as big of issue and he's free to do the same and not feel guilty.

        We are all human, (well most of us I think are, some iin users I'm not sure about) and we all make mistakes some are more costly than others, how you pay for it is up to you!

        Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Tommythecaty

    “Is it normal to be kind of a slut?”

    Title re-edit.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Somenormie

    Pick one, two is really bad.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • litelander8

    This is super tough. Maybe tell long distance that y’all should be open to seeing other people but stay in contact.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Bunnygirl25

      Sadly, that's not an option. He'll never approve of that.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • litelander8

        That y’all break up and remain friends? Idk about you. But all the restrictions started a year ago... that’s a long time to be dragging this all out.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • Bunnygirl25

          Oh I'm sorry I thought you meant be open to seeing other people while still in the relationship.

          You guys really think I should break it off with my 5 year boyfriend?

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • litelander8

            Just being real with you babe. You cheated on him. And not even some random dude. A guy that you felt passion for... yeah. I think he deserves to be dumped so he can find some passion too.

            Comment Hidden ( show )
  • LloydAsher

    Nope

    Comment Hidden ( show )