Is this incest?

I just turned 20 back then and I'm a female. My brother was 23 about to turn 24. This is what went down...

He walked into my room and told me he has a big problem that he needs to address me with. I also just woke up. He was wearing only his boxers. When I asked him what it was he was hesitating at first but then he told me that he was having a problem "getting it up", like getting an erection. He told me he spent an hour masturbating and couldn't get it up. I asked him what I had to do and he told me that he didn't know and that he was freaking out. I got on my computer and started looking it up. My brother then typed in a website (porn) and put on a video...he then asked me if I wanted to see that he wasn't lying and that he really couldn't get it up. I told him that I didn't want to see "it" because it was disgusting. He begged me to let him and telling me that he had nowhere else to go with this. Well I love my older brother and I felt bad. I told him to hurry up before our parents got back. He pulled his little penis out and started going up and down on it with his two fingers while concentrating on porn. His dick got some "life" in it but not all the way. He then stopped and we discussed what was going on. He then had me remove my night gown. I remember I was so afraid that either our mom or dad would wake up and walk in on the scene of their half naked daughter watching their son playing with his dick...either way they never did.

My brother finally got hard. No matter how disgusting I thought the whole thing was his dick impressed me. I haven't had many intimate situations with men at that point in my life and what I saw between my brother's legs was the biggest one I've seen. My brother then sat in front of me and jerked himself off. Not gonna lie I was pretty turned on the whole time watching him masturbate.

Now is this considered incest? It's been a few years since and I never told anybody. My brother and I never talked about it either. Is it still incest even though I never touched him and only watched? Well he saw me half naked too.

Voting Results
69% Normal
Based on 1301 votes (898 yes)
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 33 )
  • jordi86

    Look girl you're brother wants to have sex with you... I mean, I have jerked off watching my sister in her room while she watches porn but I'm hidden behind her half-closed door. If you got that far it means you want your brother too... So I suggest you to get the gulls, enter in your brother's room and ask him to let him see if he solved his problem... Maybe this time you could help him a little more

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Rocket_9

      ...very bad advice.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • abnormalhuman

    dear, ur brothers intention was to have sex with u. unfortunately u couldnt understand it. after getting it over he felt ashamed of it, that's y he didnt talk about it later. long time after that u r also fantazising having sex with ur brother. that's y u r here with this question. if u r interested, u can go directly to ur brother, coz he already likes it. but take care of urself not to be pregnant by ur brother.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • ZOR69

    What puzzles me about this story is, first you say your parents were out, that you were worried they would get back and find you and your brother like that, then you say they were asleep, that you were afraid they would wake up. That is confusing. They were either gone off or they were there sleeping in another room. I would be more worried if they were nearby, like in another room than if they were gone off. The chances you would hear them coming back seem pretty good, unless maybe your room is on the backside of the house.

    But... to your problem. Yes, it could have led to incest, and that may have been what he had in mind when he came in your room. But it didn't. It may have led to some incestual thoughts, from what you wrote. But nothing much really happened. You didn't do anything wrong. It would not have been that big a deal if you had've touched him or jerked him off. So what if you are turned on by his big dick? That is nothing to be ashamed of. If you want to fuck him, ask him how he feels about it. Otherwise, just fantasize, and don't feel guilty about it. There is NOTHING wrong with fantasizing about anything. If it helps get you off, then it serves it's purpose. So don't be so hard on yourself, or beat yourself up over this incident. Even if you and he had fucked, hell that is not an unforgivable sin either. Now if your parents had caught you doing THAT, then I guess there would have been hell to pay. Depends on the parents. But by all means be kind to yourself. It is a cinch that a lot of people on sites like this won't be.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Incest101

    You should've gone all the way sister!
    If it happens again ride his pinner and fuck the night away.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • red678

    I dont consider that incest, its more like sexual-exhibition. I think your brother made up that story so he could fuck you or at least masterbate in front of you. It seems you would've wanted to experiment with him too

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Krogon12

    it isn't incest. You didn't fuck right?
    But if you want to fuck him, just do it. Then it will be incest, but what's wrong with that??

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Janie2T

    Well, that may not be full scale incest, but it is definitely leaning in that direction, and probably there have been cases of incest that started in that fashion.

    My brother and I started out wrestling and fooling around in the nude, and partially nude, at a real young age, and eventually had intercourse in the shower, for a few minutes, when we was 15. I pulled away from him after a few, because I was afraid he would shoot in me and knock me up, then I squatted and sucked him off. I told him to get some condoms and he could fuck me all he wanted. So he did and we began a HOT affair, so sometimes we would just fuck all night! Made it hard on us the next day, tho, going to school and doing farm chores!

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • michaelperez

      Hi Janie2T

      I love your experience which is a bit similar to mine. I am now in my early 40s. I have been desiring to have sex with my older sister and made advances when I was in my early puberty years like rubbing my thighs with her, or caressing her thighs sometimes out of the view of others. This fantasy never wears out up to now. I had sex with a lot of women in the past but my life seems to feel still empty and sex starved unless I fuck my sister. Problem is, she is still single and a virgin and not very much open to sex. We never had any physical intimacy despite living in one roof. A very conservative family, that is. Neither one of us has seen any parts of our bodies covered by our clothes, e.g. thighs, breast, etc.

      I just wish we have the same open and liberated mind like yours. Ohhh, I am dying to have sex with her for so many, many years. I just don't know how to seduce her.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • cybad

    You are lucky it did not go any further. I mean, let's face it, close relatives should not be that "close". There has to be limits. If certain bounderies are crossed, then anything can happen. Your bro was clearly fantasizing about you. He masturbates to porn so much that it takes more than porn to get him up. Next he will get mom to help him with his "problem". Wisen up, guys. There are so many sex-starved people out there, only a coward would want to screw a close relative

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • applie13

    shesamystery, she's asking advice, dont be a wanker

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • theRealDeal

    Been there, done more than that-unfortunatly!

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • I don't know what it is, but it's not normal.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Sean666

    Well maybe he was just was actually freaked out and he wanted help, probably he trusts you a lot!

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • I don't think it's normal. I think your brother acted very inappropriately towards you even though you never touched each other.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Andy20.

    Fuck him and see how turned on u get comment back please

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • laura80

    Compared to me jacking my brother off and getting caught and whipped in front of each other by our stepdad totally nude that’s nothing

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • SHAKEStheClown

    Whatever it is it's fucked up and very wrong!

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • watcher2005

    Try a little mutual masturbation. You both can get your rock off without crossing the "incest" line. It's natural to experiment.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Greg25

    IMHO, incest requires two people to at least touch each other. While I agree your brother's conduct was "inappropriate," I would also call it "normal." I suspect that if brothers who had sisters answered honestly, the vast majority would admit that they'd fantasized about their sister at least once.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Boobylover

    This got me hard. IIN?

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Incest is sex(intercourse) with a family member. You are no where close to incest.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • michaelperez

    Tell me please, do you also have a desire to have sex with your brother? I noticed in your story that you were at one point turned on by the site of him jerking off and quite impressed with the size of his dick.

    If your brother asked you to have sex with him, will you agree and forget all about the incest stuff?

    Incest, in my own opinion, isn't bad at all for consenting adults provided procreation is avoided. There are stories that say it is a wonderful experience for siblings who fulfill their physical needs with an open mind. They become much closer with a two-pronged love, being a lover and a sibling. Lot of civilized countries do not forbid incest for as long as it is a consensual sex. I myself want to have sex with my older sister and this desire have been staying with me for so many years but never had a chance. Our family is not open to sex discussion and find it hard to discuss this thing to my sister much less to invite her to do it with me.

    I wish we have the same open-mindedness as you two have.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • midnight007

    Made up, loser

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • boner88

    Me and my sister masturbate all the time

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Ryan556

    At some point it happens I jacked off so much when I was 12-18 even tho I have a gf at one point I fucked a sister

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Avant-Garde

    How odd...

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • okbaby

    I don't think that was insisted at all.
    The worst it was a peep show and I say peopl because you weren't totally nude and you never touched each other.
    By the sounds of it it never happened again so what's the big deal.
    Have a great day and enjoy your life.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Anonny

    It's not incest yet but if you both are healthy physically mature people who are both single, then there is absolutely nothing wrong with you and him fulfilling each other's physical needs. If he wants it and you want it then go into his room tell him how you feel and i guarantee he will be naked before you can finish your sentence provided you are attractive. I have a sister and don't find her attractive but i wouldn't do something like what you wrote unless i did want it to go somewhere.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Llouisex

    Lucky brother having someone as loving as you.Marry him.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Rocket_9

    ...its not incest, its just ince.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • stikyfangers

    very close

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • jessica2727

    You need to seek professional help, obviously.

    Comment Hidden ( show )