Is this the right breed for her?

Today my grandma and I were at the flea market and we saw some German Shepherds for sale. There were 8 of them and the owners were Amish. I felt they were very serious about their dogs. As my grandmother discussed price ($500-$700), I asked about socialization. They are like family to them apparently, and they grew up around horses and sheep and cats and all that good shit, which is important because my grandma has cats. 4 of them. Dogs have been around the cats, because my grandmother's friends have dogs they bring over occasionally.

But, why does my grandmother want a dog?
Recently my grandma was diagnosed with breast cancer. She loses her balance occasionally and she wants a dog that can help her up, so a big, strong dog is necessary (BTW, the Germies are from the work line). My grandma currently lives in a two bedroom apartment but is soon moving into a 2 bedroom 1 story house with partial fencing, but HUD is going to go in and fix it up and make it completely fenced in. The backyard is approx. 30 feet by 40 feet in diameter and has a smaller, broken up shed a few inches off the ground that we can easily convert into shelter for him/her. There is a hole in the side of it so all we have to do is cut out a bigger hole in the side and wallah.

I know this is an active breed, but the house is walking distance away from me and my 2 cousins. I plan on giving it about 1 walk and a run in the nearby fields along with my Boston Terrier Reni daily, and weekly, again with my dog Reni, to the dog park to run around and be free, etc. Here in Michigan we have warmer summers and colder winters, so we can get it a pool so (s)he keeps cool and they will be fine in winter.

Sorry this is kind of rambling on, but I want to make sure my grandma makes the right decision. Thank you for reading.

Get one! These people seem serious. 14
Don't get one, it isn't the right breed for you 6
Other (Leave Comment) 4
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 7 )
  • thegypsysailor

    There are dogs especially bred and trained to aid the elderly (among other things) that would probably be much more suited to her needs.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • RoseIsabella

    There are a lot of Amish run puppy mills out there so be careful! Maybe your grandma could look into a service dog? A puppy can be a handful.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Ep1cWaffles

      The owners wanted us to come down to their property to see the adults. I'm pretty sure that if they are pressuring us to see their dogs at their property then they aren't trying to hide anything. And remember that I would be over there a lot, so it would be the both of us PLUS my 2 cousins and aunt.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • RomeoDeMontague

    What PS sailor said. They have specially trained animals for helping the elderly. Getting any random old dog just isnt going to cut it. If its a puppy I would especially advice against it. If she is old and cant get up there is not a lot she can do to train a puppy so that would be very stressful for her.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • dirtybirdy

    As long as she's not jewish.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Ep1cWaffles

      She isn't...

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • German Shepherds will kill you in your sleep, they have the same brains as sheep.

    Comment Hidden ( show )