Which person would you choose to be with?

I'm a female so change the he to she if it helps. I'm wondering what's the best move.

*Person 1:*
Your ex whom you had everything in common with, you still love more than anyone but you have been separated for 3 years. You felt understood, happy and appreciated. You only broke up because it was incredibly long distance at the time but now you're moving closer to where he lives for a job opportunity. He's dated one person since you but has broke up with that person saying he never felt they were compatible as a couple.

Relationships history: He's only dated 3 people total but his relationships lasted a while.

Attractiveness: You think he's the most attractive man you've ever seen. You are highly attracted to him.

#######################

*Person 2:*
Your best friend. You don't have too much in common but you enjoy each other's company and hang out often and have a lot of fun together. You love him a lot and he cares for you and is there for you but it's never been romantic feelings.

Relationship history: He's never been in a relationship but he used to sleep around a lot because he had sex addiction but he went to therapy and has abstained for 5 years and is a different person.

Attractiveness: He's average looking to you, you don't find him too attractive.